Getting There: The Epic Struggle between Road and Rail in the American Century (Chicago Lectures in Mathematics) | 
 enlarge | Author: Stephen B. Goddard
Publisher: University Of Chicago Press
Category: Book
List Price: $16.00
Buy Used: $6.49
You Save: $9.51 (59%)
New (8) from $14.37
Avg. Customer Rating:  3 reviews
Sales Rank: 254966
Media: Paperback
Number Of Items: 1
Pages: 366
Shipping Weight (lbs): 1.1
Dimensions (in): 9.1 x 6.1 x 0.8
ISBN: 0226300439
Dewey Decimal Number: 388.0973
EAN: 9780226300436
ASIN: 0226300439
Publication Date: November 15, 1996
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Shipping: Expedited shipping available
Shipping: International shipping available
Condition: apparently unread; "Like New" in all respects. No writing.
|
| Editorial Reviews:
Product Description
"A readable and concise overview of how U.S. transportation came to its
present pass. . . . Goddard is at his best when recounting the complex
and interesting history of what has come to be called 'the highway
lobby.'. . . An excellent book for the general reader with an interest
in getting around."—Larry Fish, Philadelphia Inquirer
"This is a riveting story: of mighty railroads hamstrung almost
overnight by government bureaucrats; of road interests led by General
Motors Corp. conspiring in city after city to destroy efficient trolley
systems . . . and of freeways that are far from free."—Bill Laitner,
Detroit Free Press
"The combination of forces and fates that turned America into a giant
parking lot from sea to shining sea is the subject of Stephen B.
Goddard's lively pop history. . . . As Mr. Goddard ably points out,
road-building and the creation of car-dependent suburbs have become ends
in themselves."—James Howard Kunstler, Wall Street Journal
"The strength of Goddard's book is that he understands the complexities
of manipulating public opinion to influence legislatures."—David
Young, Chicago Tribune
"[Goddard's] book is a deft and easily read history of how
transportation has shaped the nation and its economy, and ultimately,
how a federation of truck and car interests drastically tilted national
policies. . . . For many reasons this is an exceptionally important
work."—Jim Dwyer, New York Newsday
|
| Customer Reviews:
 A good read, but not balanced December 3, 2007
3 out of 3 found this review helpful
The author knows a lot about railroads- about their history, their operation, and their economics. And it is this knowledge which makes this book a good (and informative) read.
But, it is not at all balanced- rather, it is all too obvious that the author really likes railroads and really doesn't much care for motor transport.
And, therefore, he seems to "cherry pick" his facts- not that any are false, just that they're incomplete. For example, he notes that Amtrack's subsidy is tiny compared with highway subsidies- which is true, but, he neglects to note that Amtrack's subsidy *per passenger-mile* is enormously greater. Nor is he about to point out that NYC's extensive subway system actually uses more energy (again, per passenger-mile) than a commuter's car.
Nor does he identify the real reason why, outside of a few very congested areas, the public consistently chooses to drive rather use public transportation- and, no, it's not the government subsidies. It's because transit (local or inter-city, present-day or "golden age") is almost always a 3-seat solution: there's a branch line to the mainline, the mainline, and then another branch line to your destination. And therefore it takes too long, and is too inconvenient, and (dare I say it?)becomes too costly and inefficient. Without the ability to offer a door-to-door ride, those who can will almost always choose to drive.
But, the author does know lots about trains- and that (if you can ignore the anti-highway bias) still makes this book a worthwile read.
 How Did We Get Into This Mess March 21, 2001
16 out of 17 found this review helpful
Of all of the books that I have read pertaining to railroad history, "Getting There" is head and shoulders above all the rest. The author provides a well written and generally balanced account of the competition between rail and highway transportation in the United States from about the 1920's forward.By 1920, the powerful presence of the robber barons of the late 19th century had disappeared, and the railroads were in a state of disarray and disintegration as a result of the heavy demands being placed upon the system, and the benign dictatorship of the United States Railroad Administration (USRA) who took over and ran the railroads during WWI. In addition, the railroads were required to operate under onerous and restrictive rules and regulations imposed by the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) as a result of the excesses of the 19th century. And the railroads had little support from the public because of these past sins. Into this scenario arose highway competition, by and large developed with public funds. And without controls such as imposed on the railroads. In contrast trucks and busses were allowed to operate unfettered. So a trucking company could operate freely between two given points and change rates and service at will. While a railroad operating between those same two points would have to go through the cumbersome ICC process. Author Goddard provides a concise and well documented picture of this competition between rail and highway, a competition which continues to this day. I highly recommed this book to anyone who is interested in a serious look at our overall transportation system. But a word of advice: Check the condition of your pacemaker first. This book is not recommended for someone with high blood pressure. I guarantee that you will come away absolutely furious at the foibles of our national transportation policy.
How highways, with massive gov't subsidies, beat railroads August 7, 1999
16 out of 18 found this review helpful
A well-written readable, and mostly objective picture of how highways, through massive government investment through the construction of the interstate highway system, steadily became the dominant mode of transportation in the US. The author concludes that, with deregulation and improvements to Amtrak, railroads do have a promising future despite the historic imbalance.
|
|
|
